Live At Andrew's House was recorded at Carnegie Hall on 11 November, 2011, four months before Burr taped his third hour-long special, You People Are All The Same, on 3 March, 2012. The album gives fans the opportunity to experience a landmark performance in Burr's career and the early workings of a set that became Burr's critically-acclaimed third special.

"As a stand-up comedian, to get to perform at Carnegie Hall is a milestone; so when I found out that I got that gig, I knew I wanted to document the performance. Most of the material on this album is the same material that eventually became the special You People Are All The Same and I didn't want to screw over people by putting out two DVD's with similar material. So this is a special release of that performance that will be on vinyl only."